State Defense Forces & Disaster Preparedness: Enhancing State Emergency Capacity cover

State Defense Forces & Disaster Preparedness: Enhancing State Emergency Capacity

Zachary Federico, Jonathan Williams, Lee Schalk & Christian Whittle • September 1, 2026

The Increasing Relevance of State Defense Forces

SDFs are uniquely equipped to fill the gaps left by the National Guard’s evolving mission. The Total Force Doctrine, which was created in the 1970s, integrated the active-duty forces, Reserves, and National Guard into one homogeneous force. The policy evolved in 2012 to the Army Total Force Policy (ATFP) which partially streamlined the process for deploying the Reserves and National Guard. While the new policies strengthened the federal government’s national security mission, they left states with a void as the Guard’s training shifted toward federal priorities over state missions and its deployment tempo increased. As a result, states are often required to rely on federal agencies and other states for emergency response when their National Guard is deployed.

Additionally, the ATFP has reinforced the National Guard’s focus on federal priorities for force allocation. Since the National Guard is primarily funded by the federal government, Congress and the National Guard Bureau determine how many guardsmen each state can recruit based exclusively on federal needs. For example, Florida has been allocated just over 12,000 guardsmen since 1958, despite frequent natural disasters and a population that has more than quadrupled. While Florida’s needs have increased, the federal government’s needs for the Florida National Guard have not, preventing the Sunshine State from expanding its ranks. This led Gov. Ron DeSantis to reestablish the Florida State Guard in 2022 to bolster the state’s manpower during emergencies.

Even in states with a large National Guard force allocation, deployments can leave the state shorthanded in emergencies as a significant portion of a state’s police, firefighters, and emergency response personnel also serve as members of the National Guard.

Further, the ATFP essentially guarantees that in the case of a major conflict, the majority or totality of National Guard units would be federalized, leaving a major internal security gap for states. This has led the Department of War and the National Guard Bureau to endorse states establishing SDFs to fill the gap left by National Guard mobilizations. Unlike the National Guard, SDFs cannot be mobilized by the federal government and are always available to serve their state when needed.